Questions/Comments/Ideas about Chapter 12 - Wester Middle School

Matthew W · Matthew W

How do you think Smaug had remembered the smell of dwarves?

Katherine W · Katherine W

What do you think would have happened to the dwarves by now if not for Bilbo?

Kate M · Kate M

Why do you think Bilbo had talk in a mysterious way when dealing with Smaug? Why couldn't he just say who he was?

Holly A · Holly A

Ok, what were your thoughts on Smaug. My first thought was his name. "Smog" is a mixture of smoke and fog. So, yeah. Also i think it's very fitting that his scales shine like a treasure themselves.

Kyle S · Kyle S

At the end of chapter 12 on page 209 (in my version of the book) it said that Smaug flew off south towards the running river after he yelled, "but if you are not one of thsoe of men of the Lake you had their help. They shall see me and remember who is the real King under the Mountain!" Where do you t...

Jacqueline G · Jacqueline G

OK so do you think Bilbo played it smart when he didn't give away his real name? If you were in Bilbo's place would you have been that fast to improvise on what to say, what would you have done in the "heat" of the moment?

Ashlee S · Ashlee S

Why did he go down the secert tunnel? Also, did you think it was smart of him not to give away his name?

Amanda T · Amanda T

If Smaug has no important need for the gold and jewels then why did he go and kill all those people for it? Its not like he doen't get what he wants I mean he's a huge fire breathing dragon.

Eric S · Eric S

Do you think it is a little weird that Smaug noticed when one little thing was gone? If you were rich like him would you care if one tiny cup was stolen???

Lexus W · Lexus W

Well you know how when Bilbo was conversating with Smaug and acted like he wasn't afraid to be in his presence. How would you have reacted? What would you have done in Bilbo's place?

Amanda T · Amanda T

Do you think Bilbo and company are stuck inside smaug's mountian???

Courtney D · Courtney D

I'm sort of confused about the way Smaug talks. Like on page 243, or something in my book, it says that Smaug is trying to trick Bilbo and trying to get him to betray Thorin & Co with his dragon magic. Dragon magic? I mean really. How does it work? What would it make Bilbo do? Like, let Smaug eat h...

Hunter W · Hunter W

Why would Bilbo steal only one piece of gold? Why not as much as he could carry?

Daniel R · Daniel R

Why doesn't Smaug have the secret door bloked up already? Also why does he have to smash the whole thing.

Haley M · Haley M

On page 243 Smaug is talking to Bilbo and he is trying to influence him to believe something else. He tells him that you will go to a bad end if you stay with such friends (the dwarves). Later on during the chapter Bilbo believes Smaug and starts to question whether or not Smaug was right- f...

Haley M · Haley M

No offense to Bilbo or anything, but is it just me or is Bilbo getting pretty annoying about how he keeps on saying I wish I were at home and wants to return so badly? I know that I would be homesick too but even the dwarves seemed somewhat annoyed that Bilbo is like "whoa is me!!!" all the time whe...

Ariana V · Ariana V

So Smaug like the treasure so much that he knows that if anyone touches it he would come after you, but why? even though your rich or poor.Do you think he greedy for not shareing it? But also where did he get the treasure in the first place? tricky Question.

Matthew W · Matthew W

What do you think wouldve happened to bilbo and the dwarves if smaug was down there when they went down the tunnel?

Lindsay E · Lindsay E

If Smaug had those laser eyes that could help him see in the dark wouldn't the light from his eyes cast Bilbos shadow because it said on page 56 that if the ring wearer were to be in light he would cast a shadow.

Kate M · Kate M

Why do you think that Smaug is such a weirdo and flipped out when he noticed that a tiny golden cup was stolen? I know he's greedy, but how did he even notice that it was gone? The book said that he was able to count it and know it to the ounce, but come on!

Meredith G · Meredith G

On page 222 (in the little green book) it says, "But Bilbo was not quite so unlearned in dragon-lore as all that, and if Smaug hoped to get him to come nearer so easily he was dissapointed." How do you think Bilbo knows about dragon-lore if he didn't even know who Smaug was in the beginning of th...

Ashley P · Ashley P

Okay so everyone has a weak spot even a big scary fire-breathing dragon. So on page 203 Smaug says, " I am armoured above and below with scales and hard gems. No blade can pierce me". Little did he know that Bilbo saw the little bare patch on his breast. Why do you think Smaug showed that to Bilbo...

Lindsay K · Lindsay K

Is it just me or has Bilbo already earned his share of the treasure on top having to get them inside the mountain and slaying the dragon? On p. 212 it says, ' now is the time for him to earn his reward.' but Bilbo has been a very good burgular so far and i think they expect a little much from him.

Lindsay K · Lindsay K

So all dragons like treasure right? p.23 'they guard their plunder as long as they live' What would dragons do with treasure? Do they spend it? Or simply show it off? Or since p.23 'they can't make a thing for themselves, not even mend a loose scale ofarmour' do they use the items. I guess Smaug uses his as...

Ashley P · Ashley P

The author reveals something about the dragons sense of smell that is not known by any of the characters. He says that Smaug has a good sense of smell for most everything except hobbit's. Do you think Bilbo will figure this out? Do you think this will help them in their adventure? If so how?

Jessica C · Jessica C

On pg 215 Bilbo sees gold "wrought and unwrought" and all other kinds of gold items. Well, most of it has to be pure gold right? Pure gold is kind of kind of soft right? So what happens when a giant dragon lays on a pile of pure gold coins in a really hot room? It all mushes together into one immo...

Jessica C · Jessica C

"Theives! Fire! Murder! Such a thing had not happened since first he came to the mountain!" This one little piece confuzzled me. (pg217) Thieves-he's a thief. Fire- He breathes fire Murder- Don't innocent people and troops of ponies count? Care to clarify please?

Jessica C · Jessica C

Okay peeps! For those of you who read Gollum's Past, here's Smaug's Past! We know Smaug: -destroys towns -Steal plunder -Eats ponies (haha) -Is VERY SMART/CUNNING -not nice. Yeah. - Is a dragon (just thought I'd put that in there) Any CREATIVE ideas about where he: -Was born/grew up? ...

Jessica C · Jessica C

(pg 230-231 INSIDE INFORMATION) Thorin tells Bilbo he may pick his share of the plunder. He also seems really interested in the Arkenstone of Thrain. -Do you think Bilbo will want the Arkenstone if it is there? -If so, do you think he will keep it a secret or tell everyone? -If he tells everyone,...

Kyle S · Kyle S

What would you do in Thorin and Co's place if Smaug was tormenting you inside that tunnel?.... Wait and hope the door doesn't give way, retaliate, or...?

Topic		Started By	Replies	Views	Last Post
	Smell? (Preview) How do you think Smaug had remembered the smell of dwarves?	Matthew W	2	2411	Thu Dec 27 5:41 PM, 2007 by Katie B
	would the dwarves survive? (Preview) What do you think would have happened to the dwarves by now if not for Bilbo?	Katherine W	6	1498	Wed Dec 19 9:22 AM, 2007 by Lexus W
	Dragon Talk (Preview) Why do you think Bilbo had talk in a mysterious way when dealing with Smaug? Why couldn't he just say who he was?	Kate M	4	1341	Wed Dec 19 9:18 AM, 2007 by Lexus W
	The Dragon, Smaug (Preview) Ok, what were your thoughts on Smaug. My first thought was his name. "Smog" is a mixture of smoke and fog. So, yeah. Also i think it's very fitting that his scales shine like a treasure themselves.	Holly A	3	1431	Tue Dec 18 6:58 PM, 2007 by Brian S
	Smaug's gone where? (Preview) At the end of chapter 12 on page 209 (in my version of the book) it said that Smaug flew off south towards the running river after he yelled, "but if you are not one of thsoe of men of the Lake you had their help. They shall see me and remember who is the real King under the Mountain!" Where do you t...	Kyle S	6	1277	Tue Dec 18 9:55 AM, 2007 by Chloe V
	riddles for a name? (Preview) OK so do you think Bilbo played it smart when he didn't give away his real name? If you were in Bilbo's place would you have been that fast to improvise on what to say, what would you have done in the "heat" of the moment?	Jacqueline G	5	1383	Tue Dec 18 9:52 AM, 2007 by Chloe V
	Biblo. (Preview) Why did he go down the secert tunnel? Also, did you think it was smart of him not to give away his name?	Ashlee S	0	1340	Tue Dec 18 9:48 AM, 2007 by Ashlee S
	Gold??? (Preview) If Smaug has no important need for the gold and jewels then why did he go and kill all those people for it? Its not like he doen't get what he wants I mean he's a huge fire breathing dragon.	Amanda T	3	1305	Tue Dec 18 9:47 AM, 2007 by Chloe V
	Treasure (Preview) Do you think it is a little weird that Smaug noticed when one little thing was gone? If you were rich like him would you care if one tiny cup was stolen???	Eric S	2	1331	Tue Dec 18 9:45 AM, 2007 by Chloe V
	Scared out of your pants........ (Preview) Well you know how when Bilbo was conversating with Smaug and acted like he wasn't afraid to be in his presence. How would you have reacted? What would you have done in Bilbo's place?	Lexus W	0	1188	Tue Dec 18 9:31 AM, 2007 by Lexus W
	Stuck? (Preview) Do you think Bilbo and company are stuck inside smaug's mountian???	Amanda T	1	1182	Tue Dec 18 8:04 AM, 2007 by Joella I
	Dragon Magic (Preview) I'm sort of confused about the way Smaug talks. Like on page 243, or something in my book, it says that Smaug is trying to trick Bilbo and trying to get him to betray Thorin & Co with his dragon magic. Dragon magic? I mean really. How does it work? What would it make Bilbo do? Like, let Smaug eat h...	Courtney D	0	1103	Tue Dec 18 8:01 AM, 2007 by Courtney D
	Bilbo stealing. (Preview) Why would Bilbo steal only one piece of gold? Why not as much as he could carry?	Hunter W	1	1187	Tue Dec 18 7:43 AM, 2007 by TJB
	Smaug and the Secret door (Preview) Why doesn't Smaug have the secret door bloked up already? Also why does he have to smash the whole thing.	Daniel R	7	1403	Tue Dec 18 7:08 AM, 2007 by Eric S
	The dwarves and Bilbo (Preview) On page 243 Smaug is talking to Bilbo and he is trying to influence him to believe something else. He tells him that you will go to a bad end if you stay with such friends (the dwarves). Later on during the chapter Bilbo believes Smaug and starts to question whether or not Smaug was right- f...	Haley M	0	1278	Mon Dec 17 7:07 PM, 2007 by Haley M
	Annoying Bilbo?? (Preview) No offense to Bilbo or anything, but is it just me or is Bilbo getting pretty annoying about how he keeps on saying I wish I were at home and wants to return so badly? I know that I would be homesick too but even the dwarves seemed somewhat annoyed that Bilbo is like "whoa is me!!!" all the time whe...	Haley M	0	1219	Mon Dec 17 6:30 PM, 2007 by Haley M
	Where did the treasure come from? (Preview) So Smaug like the treasure so much that he knows that if anyone touches it he would come after you, but why? even though your rich or poor.Do you think he greedy for not shareing it? But also where did he get the treasure in the first place? tricky Question.	Ariana V	0	1492	Mon Dec 17 4:25 PM, 2007 by Ariana V
	No Smaug? (Preview) What do you think wouldve happened to bilbo and the dwarves if smaug was down there when they went down the tunnel?	Matthew W	0	1215	Mon Dec 17 3:47 PM, 2007 by Matthew W
	Smaugs eyes (Preview) If Smaug had those laser eyes that could help him see in the dark wouldn't the light from his eyes cast Bilbos shadow because it said on page 56 that if the ring wearer were to be in light he would cast a shadow.	Lindsay E	0	1163	Mon Dec 17 10:44 AM, 2007 by Lindsay E
	Greedy Smaug. (Preview) Why do you think that Smaug is such a weirdo and flipped out when he noticed that a tiny golden cup was stolen? I know he's greedy, but how did he even notice that it was gone? The book said that he was able to count it and know it to the ounce, but come on!	Kate M	0	1319	Mon Dec 17 10:10 AM, 2007 by Kate M
	dragon-lore (Preview) On page 222 (in the little green book) it says, "But Bilbo was not quite so unlearned in dragon-lore as all that, and if Smaug hoped to get him to come nearer so easily he was dissapointed." How do you think Bilbo knows about dragon-lore if he didn't even know who Smaug was in the beginning of th...	Meredith G	2	1284	Mon Dec 17 8:51 AM, 2007 by Katherine W
	Weak Spot!!!!!! (Preview) Okay so everyone has a weak spot even a big scary fire-breathing dragon. So on page 203 Smaug says, " I am armoured above and below with scales and hard gems. No blade can pierce me". Little did he know that Bilbo saw the little bare patch on his breast. Why do you think Smaug showed that to Bilbo...	Ashley P	1	1263	Mon Dec 17 8:23 AM, 2007 by Brittany C
	Bilbo's Share of the Treasure (Preview) Is it just me or has Bilbo already earned his share of the treasure on top having to get them inside the mountain and slaying the dragon? On p. 212 it says, ' now is the time for him to earn his reward.' but Bilbo has been a very good burgular so far and i think they expect a little much from him.	Lindsay K	0	1138	Sun Dec 16 5:33 PM, 2007 by Lindsay K
	Dragon Plunder (Preview) So all dragons like treasure right? p.23 'they guard their plunder as long as they live' What would dragons do with treasure? Do they spend it? Or simply show it off? Or since p.23 'they can't make a thing for themselves, not even mend a loose scale ofarmour' do they use the items. I guess Smaug uses his as...	Lindsay K	0	1097	Sun Dec 16 5:24 PM, 2007 by Lindsay K
	Smaug's sense of smell (Preview) The author reveals something about the dragons sense of smell that is not known by any of the characters. He says that Smaug has a good sense of smell for most everything except hobbit's. Do you think Bilbo will figure this out? Do you think this will help them in their adventure? If so how?	Ashley P	0	1282	Sun Dec 16 4:35 PM, 2007 by Ashley P
	Smaug and his Mushy Mushy Gold (Preview) On pg 215 Bilbo sees gold "wrought and unwrought" and all other kinds of gold items. Well, most of it has to be pure gold right? Pure gold is kind of kind of soft right? So what happens when a giant dragon lays on a pile of pure gold coins in a really hot room? It all mushes together into one immo...	Jessica C	2	1906	Sun Dec 16 6:31 AM, 2007 by Meredith G
	Theives! Fire! Murder! Such a thing had not happened since... (Preview) "Theives! Fire! Murder! Such a thing had not happened since first he came to the mountain!" This one little piece confuzzled me. (pg217) Thieves-he's a thief. Fire- He breathes fire Murder- Don't innocent people and troops of ponies count? Care to clarify please?	Jessica C	2	1129	Sun Dec 16 6:27 AM, 2007 by Meredith G
	Smaug's Past (Preview) Okay peeps! For those of you who read Gollum's Past, here's Smaug's Past! We know Smaug: -destroys towns -Steal plunder -Eats ponies (haha) -Is VERY SMART/CUNNING -not nice. Yeah. - Is a dragon (just thought I'd put that in there) Any CREATIVE ideas about where he: -Was born/grew up? ...	Jessica C	1	994	Sat Dec 15 1:36 PM, 2007 by Jessica C
	The Arkenstone...and trouble.(MAY BE A SPOILER!) (Preview) (pg 230-231 INSIDE INFORMATION) Thorin tells Bilbo he may pick his share of the plunder. He also seems really interested in the Arkenstone of Thrain. -Do you think Bilbo will want the Arkenstone if it is there? -If so, do you think he will keep it a secret or tell everyone? -If he tells everyone,...	Jessica C	0	1145	Sat Dec 15 1:28 PM, 2007 by Jessica C
	What would you do? (Preview) What would you do in Thorin and Co's place if Smaug was tormenting you inside that tunnel?.... Wait and hope the door doesn't give way, retaliate, or...?	Kyle S	0	1017	Fri Dec 14 7:53 AM, 2007 by Kyle S
1 2 > Last» \| Page of 2 sorted by