Chapters 5 - 8 Commentary/Questions - Wester Middle School

Pamela T · Pamela T

If Bilbo was chosen by Gandalf to go on this journey and Bilbo is the main character then why isn't he leading the treasure hunt? I think that if he's the main character then he should be leading the journey. Maybe when we get further into the book he will become the leader.

Chad S · Chad S

At first he wasn't hungry but later he became hungry so since Gollum has the capability of killing Bilbo, why do you think that he didn't just kill him and eat him before Bilbo saw him instead of playing games and loosing? Why do you think he didn't kill him after he lost, because Bilbo cheated and didn't s...

Lindsay E · Lindsay E

I was a little confuse at Beorns "powers."Is he like an animal man or a man animal??Can he only turn into a bear or any kind of animal??

Lindsay E · Lindsay E

If you haven't read chapter 7 just yet then you wouldn't know who he is!!=]]

Topic		Started By	Replies	Views	Last Post
	Bilbo a leader?? (Preview) If Bilbo was chosen by Gandalf to go on this journey and Bilbo is the main character then why isn't he leading the treasure hunt? I think that if he's the main character then he should be leading the journey. Maybe when we get further into the book he will become the leader.	Pamela T	4	333	Thu Dec 6 6:20 PM, 2007 by Kayla L
	gollum (Preview) At first he wasn't hungry but later he became hungry so since Gollum has the capability of killing Bilbo, why do you think that he didn't just kill him and eat him before Bilbo saw him instead of playing games and loosing? Why do you think he didn't kill him after he lost, because Bilbo cheated and didn't s...	Chad S	4	340	Thu Dec 6 9:42 AM, 2007 by Andi W
	Beorn (Preview) I was a little confuse at Beorns "powers."Is he like an animal man or a man animal??Can he only turn into a bear or any kind of animal??	Lindsay E	2	296	Wed Dec 5 6:52 PM, 2007 by Jessica C
	Beorn (Preview) If you haven't read chapter 7 just yet then you wouldn't know who he is!!=]]	Lindsay E	0	284	Wed Dec 5 9:29 AM, 2007 by Lindsay E
«First < 1 2 3 \| Page of 3 sorted by